LifeSite News
U.S. & Politics

Cardinal Dolan denounces New York assisted suicide bill: 'Disaster waiting to happen'

By Stephen KokxMay 7, 2025 at 4:16 PM
Cardinal Dolan denounces New York assisted suicide bill: 'Disaster waiting to happen'
Tom Hannigan/Wikimedia Commons | Cardinal Timothy Dolan of New York

New York lawmakers approved a Medical Aid in Dying Act that would 'provide a mentally competent, terminally ill adult who has been given a prognosis of six months or less to live the ability to request medication from their treating physician for medical aid in dying.'

(LifeSiteNews) -- One day before casting his first vote at the conclave in the Sistine Chapel on Wednesday, New York Cardinal Timothy Dolan rebuked an assisted suicide bill that passed the state’s Assembly, or lower chamber, last Tuesday.

“This bill is a disaster waiting to happen,” His Eminence said in an op-ed for First Things. “The very idea of having a doctor give you a prescription to end your life prematurely is contrary to everything we cherish.”

Lawmakers approved the Medical Aid in Dying Act in New York by an 81-67 margin on April 29. According to a press release issued by Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie, the bill would “provide a mentally competent, terminally ill adult who has been given a prognosis of six months or less to live the ability to request medication from their treating physician for medical aid in dying.”

It would also “require both an oral request and a witnessed written request for the medication, as well as requiring at least two physicians determine that the patient has the capacity to make an informed decision on this request.”

The measure still needs to pass the New York state Senate and obtain the approval of Democratic Gov. Kathy Hochul, who identifies as a Catholic but has repeatedly supported policies directly at odds with immutable Church teaching.

Dolan rejected Heastie’s claim that the measure empowers New Yorkers to die with “dignity and choice.”

“State-sanctioned suicide turns everything society knows and believes about medicine on its head,” Dolan said. “Doctors go from healers to killers.”

“We’ve seen this happen in other states and countries that have enacted this fearsome legislation. Remember how abortion supporters’ mantra of ‘safe, legal, and rare’ was quickly cast aside, and now abortion is imposed, frequent and something to be celebrated. The same is true for assisted suicide,” he recalled.

Dolan also warned that the bill would act as a Pandora’s box used to pressure “the sick, elderly and the depressed to end their own lives.”

“Is it any wonder that insurance providers are often supporters of assisted suicide legislation, wanting to protect their bottom line from patients who might live an extra few weeks or months with proper care?” he asked.

At the same time, Heastie’s press release states that under the bill “insurers would be prohibited from recommending or providing information on medical aid in dying to patients, including alongside denial of coverage notices for other treatments.”

Assisted suicide is permitted in 10 U.S. states, including California, Montana, Hawaii, Maine, New Jersey, Vermont, Colorado, New Mexico, Oregon and Washington, as well as Washington, D.C.

U.S. & Politics
May 7, 2025 at 4:16 PM
SK

Stephen Kokx

Stephen Kokx is a journalist for LifeSiteNews. A former community college instructor, Stephen has written and spoken extensively about Catholic social teaching, politics, and spirituality. He previously worked for the Archdiocese of Chicago under the late Francis Cardinal George. His essays have appeared in a variety of outlets, including Catholic Family News and CatholicVote.org. He is the author of two books, Navigating the Crisis in the Church: Essays in Defense of Traditional Catholicism and St. Alphonsus for the 21st Century: A Handbook for Holiness.
Share:

Article At A Glance

  • New York lawmakers approved a Medical Aid in Dying Act that would 'provide a mentally competent, terminally ill adult who has been given a prognosis of six months or less to live the ability to request medication from their treating physician for medical aid in dying.'

Be the difference behind the stories that matter

Your support powers independent journalism that stands for truth. In a world of mainstream narratives, LifeSiteNews remains committed to reporting on life, faith, family, and freedom without compromise. Every donation creates ripples of impact—helping millions worldwide discover fact-based reporting on the issues that shape our culture and future. Join our community of truth-seekers making a difference today.

Donate Today

Get news in your inbox.
Subscribe to our newsletter.

Get the latest news on faith, family, and culture delivered directly to your inbox. Our newsletter provides carefully curated stories that matter to Catholics and Christians seeking truthful reporting on issues that mainstream media often overlooks. Join thousands of readers who rely on our independent journalism.

We respect your privacy.